Beauty Blogger

Little Box Horrors | Supernatural Box | May 2021


Ribbet collage

I have the next Little Box of Horrors to share with you today. The theme of the May box is Supernatural. Prior to this theme being picked, I had never watched Supernatural before, but I committed to starting the show as I was receiving products and starting to swatch. My goal was to get through the entire series before the release and I am somewhat still on track (just started season 13). On a side note, other than Castiel, I really really really hate the angels. I’m ready for them to go. I have lots of other thoughts, but I suppose this is not the right place to go into that! lol.

There are 24 brands taking part in the Supernatural box and there is a gorgeous mix of indie polishes and products all inspired by all things Supernatural. One of the things I love about this box is that polishes and products are available individually, so you can really curate your perfect box!

The Supernatural Little Box of Horrors will be available May 18th to May 30th at

The shop will open for preview Saturday, May 15th.

All swatches done using Vapid Lacquer Commitment Issues Base Coat and Get Your Shine On. Pictures taken in direct lighting with a natural daylight Ottlite.

All Mixed Up Lacquer

Tragic Circumstances


Inspired by Pilot Episode #1 The Lady in the White Dress (based on La Llorona)

Tragic Circumstances is described as a white crelly packed with golden and green shimmers, ghostly aurora shifting flakies, and a sprinkling of black holo blend.

Pictured in three coats.

Price: $11.00

Cap: 50 bottles


Anchor & Heart

Rascally Deity


Inspired by the deity who needs no introduction, notorious Daddy-O, Chuckles, and Chuck Shurly. The one, the only, God.

Rascally Deity is described as a deep olive green base that shifts with a strong gold/copper/pink shimmer and tiny copper micro glitter.

Pictured in three coats.

Price: $12.50

Cap: None



Tidal Mist Spray Lotion


The Winchester boys, perhaps they would enjoy wearing this scent!

Tidal Mist is a light, quick absorbing, spray-able lotion that takes all the effort out of application! It utilizes organic jojoba seed and coconut oils (among other amazing ingredients) and is perfectly balanced to provide softening, soothing support for dry skin of all types! Tidal Mist is vegan & cruelty free, with no added parabens, phthalates, or gluten. Formulated with 86% organic ingredients! It is very lightly scented in “Sexy As A Winchester” – a scent featuring sandalwood, cinnamon, patchouli, amber and soft musk. A decidedly genderless scent – perfect for everyone!

Price: $10.00

Cap: 50 bottles


Baroness X

Fight the Fairies!


Inspired by S6E9, the fairy attack.

Fight the Fairies is described as a deep olive, almost black base with gold to green magnetic and OGUP-like large particle shimmer that shifts red to bronze.

Pictured in two coats.

Price: $12.50

Cap: None


BCB Lacquers

Hey Ass-Butt


Hey Ass-Butt is described as a magenta holo polish with pink/red/orange/gold shifting flakies, gun metal, white and gold flakies with red and orange shimmer.

Pictured in three coats.

Price: $13.75

Cap: 75 bottles



Whipped Sugar Scrub

I Found A Liquor Storeโ€ฆAnd I Drank It


A whipped sugar scrub with a custom oil blend for hydration and exfoliation! This mouthwatering boozy scent starts with top notes of apple, red currant, red wine, cinnamon, and a hint of orange. With bottom notes of sweet maple, spice and vanilla finish off this irresistible custom fragrance oil blend. This has white and brown sugar for extra exfoliation. On top you will see a sprinkle of gold beads and gold mica.

Price: $11.50

Cap: 20 jars


Black Dahlia Lacquer



Calliope in her purple dress in season 10.

Calliope is described as a dark indigo crelly with rainbow glitter in various sizes and blue/fuchsia/purple shifting flakies.

Pictured in two coats.

Price: $11.50

Cap: None


Dark Moon Esscentuals

Dirty B*tch Activated Charcoal Instant Facial


“Dean’s use of the phrase always made me laugh-it’s also something that I heard my dad say a few times while fixing our cars!” – Aly

A hybrid of an exfoliating facial cleanser and a facial mask. This unique product is the answer to your skincare dreams!

Price: $14.00

Cap: 50 jars.


Fanchromatic Nails

I Have A Little Hell to Raise


Inspired by Crowley, the King of Hell

I Have A Little Hell to Raise is described as a multichrome polish that glows RED in the dark! This polish has a soft coppery base that shifts to gold and reddish bronze, with metallic microflakes and microglitter, and larger chameleon flakies that shift red/gold/green. This polish can be used on its own in 2-3 coats, or as a topper. Our polishes are always vegan, cruelty-free, and nontoxic!

Pictured in three coats.

Price: $12.00

Cap: None


Galatea Cosmetics

Evil Mary Poppins Bath Crush


Inspired by Mrs Butters from the season 15 episode, “Last Holiday”

Scent/color description: The scent of a malevolent wood nymph: rosewood, redwood, forest ferns, lavender and other bushy herbs, and wildflowers. Foaming Bath Crush is the perfect combination of a bath melt, bubble bath, and bath bomb. We offer it in a loose powder so you can use as much or as little as suits your fancy – we recommend 2-4oz per bath ๐Ÿ™‚ This is the ultimate de-stressor, which will also moisturize & soften your skin while you relax in your beautiful, fizzy, foamy, colorful bath ๐Ÿ™‚ Product Highlights: Adds fizz, foam, color & scent to the water Designed for sensitive skin Moisturizing & skin-softening Wonโ€™t stain your bath tub or make it slippery Reusable, resealable packaging How to Use: For maximum bubbles, toss directly under warm/hot running water as your tub fills – the more you agitate the water, the more bubbles you will get! For maximum fizzy action & softer, creamier foam, scatter on the surface of the water when the tub is full. If you don’t have a bath tub, you can also use this as a nail or foot soak ๐Ÿ™‚ Our bath crush was designed for sensitive skin – but if irritation occurs, please discontinue use immediately. Keep out of reach of children except under adult supervision. Handmade in San Francisco, CA Vegan, Cruelty-free, Nontoxic 100% Satisfaction Guarantee Free of phthalates, sulfates, and common allergens

Price: $9.00

Cap: None


Inspira Designs

Supernatural Magnet


A resin magnet in the shape of the Supernatural anti-possession symbol.

Price: $6.00

Cap: 24



The Guardian


The Guardian is described as a deep purple base with copper/gold/green shimmer.

Pictured in three coats

Price: $13.00

Cap: None


Lacquers is in the Air

Bloody Mary, Bloody Mary, Bloody…


“Inspired by one of my favorite Supernatural episodes Bloody Mary.” – Stacy

Bloody Mary, Bloody Mary, Bloody… is described as a blackened red holo base with black to red multichrome pigment.

Pictured in two coats. I got light staining when swatching this polish. A good base coat is recommended to help minimize staining.

Price: $13.00

Cap: 200 bottles



Please Accept This Sandwich


Inspired by Cas and sammiches.

Please Accept This Sandwich is described as a black base with blue magnetic pull, red to orange to yellow shifting crystal flakies, and holo micro glitters.

Pictured in three coats.

Price: $13.00

Cap: None



Mmm…Pie Wax Melt


Inspired by Dean’s love of pie.

The aroma of freshly picked blueberries, fresh cut granny smith apples, smothered in butter, cream, and cinnamon, with a background of fresh baked crust.

Price: $4.50

Cap: None


MTK Design

Eat Pie Kill Demons


Inspired by the neon sign highlighting Dean’s goals.

Eat Pie Kill Demons is described as an orange-red neon jelly with intense blue/green shimmers & sparkles w/ blue glow in the dark (the blue GitD lights up the red jelly so you may see the reddish glow, too or instead of the blue). Note: GitD can be charged under artificial light, but for long lasting glow several hours in daylight is best.

Pictured in three coats.

Price: $12.00

Cap: None


Nailed It Nail Polish

Walking On Sunshine


Inspired by Charlie Bradbury

Walking On Sunshine is described as a sheer soft blue base packed with a rainbow of gold, red, copper, and green crystal flakies.

Pictured in two coats.

Price: $13.00

Cap: 150 bottles


Paradox Polish & Soap Company

Eve Ainโ€™t Gunna Gank Herself


Inspired by Eve and Dean

Eve Ain’t Gunna Gank Herself is described as a dirty primordial pank with loads of UCC flakes that shift from pink gold green, turquoise flake, Aurora and scattered holo.

Pictured in three coats.

Price: $12.00

Cap: None



Fire & Brimstone Shea Butter Cold Process Soap


Inspired by visiting hell, escaping hell, or being the king of hell

A red and black with activated charcoal Shea butter based soap scented in fire and brimstone BBQ smell topped with the anti possession symbol.

Price: $8.00

Cap: None


Peachtree Polish

Never Underestimate the King of Hell


Inspired byย the character Crowley.

Never Underestimate the King of Hell is described as a thermal jelly that shifts from brick red (cold) to bright yellow (warm) with blue/green/gold UCC flakes.

Pictured in three coats. My pics are leaning a little orange because I could not get my hand to stay cold enough to catch the darkest shift, but please note that it does get a little darker in it’s cold state.

Price: $12.00

Cap: 50 bottles


Ribbits Stickits

The Family Business Water Slide Decals Set


Inspired by Supernatural.

Set of three sheets of water slide decals on clear backing. More than 110 images included! Sam, Dean, Castiel, Crowley, Bobby, Baby, etc! Perfect to create Supernatural manis. Instructions, tips and tricks are included.

Price: $15.00

Cap: 50 sets



Un-frog-gettable Hand and Cuticle Cream Trio


A trio of hand and cuticle creams in scents inspired by Sam, Dean and Castiel.

Price: $10.00

Cap: 40 sets


Saki Cosmetics

That Was Scary!


That Was Scary! is described as a navy polish with gold to pink magnetic pigment.

Pictured in two coats.

Price: $12.50

Cap: 50 bottles


Sassy Pants Polish

Hello Boys


Inspired byย Sam, Dean and Rowena.

Hello Boys is described as a turquoise to green to red multi-chrome magnetic holographic polish with UCC flakies and multichrome flakies.

Pictured in two coats.

Price: $12.50

Cap: 100 bottles



Rowena Cuticle Balm


Inspired by Rowena

This luxurious and moisturizing cuticle balm is enriched with all natural skin-loving ingredients and smells like a tea rose with a mysterious nuance of green and powder. Label also includes a computer rendered photo of Rowena.

Price: $6.50

Cap: 50 bottles


Treo Lacquer

I Like Past You


Inspired by Castiel in The End.ย 

I Like Past You is described as a blackened shimmery olive with blue flecks.

Pictured in two coats.

Price: $12.00

Cap: 80 bottles


Connect with Little Box of Horrors

Shop | Facebook | Instagram


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s